Putin, Trump and Xi call for UN reform: What Tokayev proposed earlier

Published
Journalist of the General News department
Photo: whitehouse.gov, photo editor: Milosh Muratovskiy

U.S. President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping agreed to push for UN reform during a trilateral summit in Shenzhen, China, on Nov. 19.

Their joint declaration on peace also addresses increased production and supply of refined petroleum products, respect for the immunity of state officials and efforts to reduce the risk of nuclear war.

As permanent members of the UN Security Council, the U.S., Russia and China pledged to support reform of the organization. The leaders said the changes should enable the UN to respond more effectively to global challenges and fulfill its primary mission of maintaining international peace and security.

Tokayev calls UN reform a «strategic necessity»

Kazakhstan’s President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev has repeatedly criticized the UN’s effectiveness and proposed changes to the composition of its Security Council. Kursiv.media revisits his key statements on the issue.

In September 2025, Tokayev warned of a growing crisis of confidence in international institutions and called for comprehensive UN reform. He made the remarks while addressing the 80th session of the UN General Assembly in New York.

«A comprehensive reform of the United Nations is a strategic necessity, not a subject for endless deliberation. The reform of the Security Council must be the central element of these efforts,» Tokayev said.

The president proposed expanding the Security Council to include major countries from Asia, Africa and Latin America. He also called for a greater role for «middle powers,» arguing that they could serve as mediators between competing geopolitical blocs.

Tokayev warned that without meaningful reforms, the UN risks becoming an organization that merely responds to the consequences of international crises rather than addressing their root causes.

‘A bad escalator and a bad teleprompter’: Tokayev echoes Trump’s criticism

In April 2026, speaking at the Antalya Diplomacy Forum, Tokayev again questioned the effectiveness of international institutions. He said the UN’s influence was rapidly declining, with negotiations to resolve armed conflicts increasingly taking place outside its framework.

Tokayev also supported Trump’s criticism of the UN during the General Assembly in September 2025.

He recalled Trump’s complaints about «a bad escalator and a bad teleprompter» at UN headquarters, arguing that the more serious problem was the breakdown of the international peace process, both within the UN and beyond.

The Kazakhstani president also criticized outdated provisions in the UN Charter, particularly references to «enemy states,» a term dating back to the aftermath of World War II.

Tokayev argued that the term had become obsolete over the past 80 years, as countries once designated as enemies now play an important role in maintaining international security and funding the UN.

He also noted that middle powers sometimes demonstrate a greater sense of responsibility in international affairs than permanent members of the Security Council.

«Middle powers often demonstrate a greater sense of responsibility than major powers — those represented on the Security Council — which, unfortunately, frequently block solutions to key global issues,» he said.

‘The UN Charter is not a menu’: Tokayev criticizes selective application of international law

In April 2026, addressing the Res 2026 Regional Environmental Summit in Astana, Tokayev warned against selectively applying the provisions of the UN Charter.

«The UN Charter is not a menu, and it cannot be approached by cherry-picking,» Tokayev said.

He argued that countries cannot choose which principles of international law to follow while ignoring others, particularly on matters of war and peace.

According to Tokayev, such practices undermine trust in international institutions and weaken their ability to address global challenges.

Why Tokayev opposes replacing the UN

Despite his criticism, Tokayev has repeatedly argued against abandoning the existing system of international cooperation.

In September 2026, speaking at the SCO Plus summit, he said that even justified criticism of the UN does not mean the organization should be replaced.

«There is a great deal of criticism directed at the UN. Even if some of that criticism is justified, it does not change the fundamental reality: there is no alternative to this organization,» he said.

Tokayev argued that the UN should remain at the center of the international system, with its Charter serving as the universal foundation of international law.

He proposed strengthening the organization’s effectiveness through closer cooperation with regional blocs, expanded preventive diplomacy and a greater role for middle powers.

It remains unclear how closely Tokayev’s proposals will align with future initiatives from the United States, Russia and China. Although all three countries have acknowledged the need for reform, their joint declaration did not specify whether they would support expanding the Security Council or changing its decision-making procedures.

Read also